One inescapable part of life in Bangladesh is being asked for "bakshish" (a tip). It's virtually impossible to walk anywhere in Dhaka without being stopped or followed by someone old, young, naked, disabled, singing, chanting, or manning a traffic light. They can range from the lighthearted, such as a little girl singing a song for you as you wait for the lights to change whilst sat on your bike (I gave her 0 Taka), to the disturbing when a man grasping an ancient prescription clutches you by the arm as you emerge from a bakery shouting "cancer" over and over again (I gave him 0 Taka).
There are 2 reactions: the 1000 mile stare. You very quickly learn in Dhaka that to make eye contact with people is an open invitation for them to ask you for something. Of course, not everyone is going to ask you for something but it is so draining when you are asked that you end up completely cutting yourself off from allowing any potential opportunity. This I personally feel is a rather a sad way to have live in a city, and so can lead to the second reaction: do a completely misinterpreted cultural event which allows you to gives something back in a structured manner in which everyone, including yourself benefits.
Every year in Spain, it is the Three Wise Men (they call them the Three Kings) who bring presents to children on the Epiphany (6th January), the same day they arrived in Bethlehem having followed the star etc. etc. Father Christmas doesn't even get a look in on Christmas Eve. So on the 5th January, children line the streets of their city or village, to watch as the kings arrive on a long procession, in which sweets and promotional items are distributd. It is a nice and frankly harmless atmosphere, and I doubt that many of the kids even realise the religious dimension of the event these days.
Of course the Spanish manage to add a personal touch, by having one of the kings (Balthasar) who is black, be played by a white man who has blacked up. Now I can imagine this may have been necessary in Franco's Spain, when perhaps the black population of Spain was very limited. But that they still choose to practice this day is pretty embarassing and actually has negative effects.
For example, one of the Cabalgatas (January 5th procession done by the Kings) I watched as a kid in my mother's village with my brothers and sisters. After we had got home, my little brother Juan who is now a young anarchist-punk local rock star, burst out in to tears, "Balthasar wasn't a real black man" he blubbered, as the whole sham of the event hit him. And I was left speechless, as a 13 year-old trying to justify Spain's closeted racism which they seemed willing to hang on to late in to the 20th Century.
Anyhow, back to the point of this post. The 1000 mile stare is so depressing, and yet so unavoidable, that there is a need to balance it and this year it was done through hosting Dhaka's first ever Cabalgata. What started as a drunken conversation on Christmas Eve, evolved in to a 15 person procession through the streets of Gulshan and Banani, replete with 3 kings riding on rickshaws, loyal pages handing out lentils, rice, sweets, juice, biscuits.
As a cultural event it was a disaster, but it did work as a method of distributing food. Firstly, we failed to plan our route very well and so chose to start from one of the only points in Bangladesh where there are no beggars to be found. The first 15 minutes of the procession were panicked as we had no children to share our gifts with, which forced us to over-compensate by going down the road on which there are numerous families trying to live. That is where our second weakness was exposed, as we had no distribution plan. All three Kings were attacked on their rickshaws as people started to grab at the food items, lifting whole bags of rice when they were only supposed to get packets. In some cases it was visible that this occured out of desperation (i.e. very hungry mothers) and in other cases it was plain theft (i.e. very rowdy youths). And this exposed our third weakness, as we hadn't actually discussed what to expect (beyond the original drunken discussion on Christmas Eve).
I thought it was great fun. A complete mess, as noone had a clue as to why foreigners were riding down the road dressed up and giving things out. So the cultural dimension was lost. But also some of the Spanish contingent were sho
cked at the reaction of the people. Remember, all their lives they have seen the event lined up at the side of the road, waiting patiently in the January cold for the Kings to role past. It was never going to be the same in Dhaka, and the people certainly weren't going to thank us. In the end the rickshaw wallahs panicked and accelerated away, leaving the kings separated from their royal escort, and the royal escort vulnerable to the ongoing attacks of the people demanding more and more food. Next year I am already planning to put the Kings on camels so that they can get a greater street-level clearance.
A lot of people have since asked why I would do such a thing using words such as proselytising and imperialism. You can get everything in Bangladesh, including $6 loaves of bread like the one I just had for my lunch. But it is hard to rationalise or be accept what you see and experience every single time you leave your house. So on serious note I did help prevent me from going crazy, or to completely cut myself off from the country. On gentler note, it was a lot more fun than NGO work.
There are 2 reactions: the 1000 mile stare. You very quickly learn in Dhaka that to make eye contact with people is an open invitation for them to ask you for something. Of course, not everyone is going to ask you for something but it is so draining when you are asked that you end up completely cutting yourself off from allowing any potential opportunity. This I personally feel is a rather a sad way to have live in a city, and so can lead to the second reaction: do a completely misinterpreted cultural event which allows you to gives something back in a structured manner in which everyone, including yourself benefits.
Every year in Spain, it is the Three Wise Men (they call them the Three Kings) who bring presents to children on the Epiphany (6th January), the same day they arrived in Bethlehem having followed the star etc. etc. Father Christmas doesn't even get a look in on Christmas Eve. So on the 5th January, children line the streets of their city or village, to watch as the kings arrive on a long procession, in which sweets and promotional items are distributd. It is a nice and frankly harmless atmosphere, and I doubt that many of the kids even realise the religious dimension of the event these days.
Of course the Spanish manage to add a personal touch, by having one of the kings (Balthasar) who is black, be played by a white man who has blacked up. Now I can imagine this may have been necessary in Franco's Spain, when perhaps the black population of Spain was very limited. But that they still choose to practice this day is pretty embarassing and actually has negative effects.
For example, one of the Cabalgatas (January 5th procession done by the Kings) I watched as a kid in my mother's village with my brothers and sisters. After we had got home, my little brother Juan who is now a young anarchist-punk local rock star, burst out in to tears, "Balthasar wasn't a real black man" he blubbered, as the whole sham of the event hit him. And I was left speechless, as a 13 year-old trying to justify Spain's closeted racism which they seemed willing to hang on to late in to the 20th Century.
Anyhow, back to the point of this post. The 1000 mile stare is so depressing, and yet so unavoidable, that there is a need to balance it and this year it was done through hosting Dhaka's first ever Cabalgata. What started as a drunken conversation on Christmas Eve, evolved in to a 15 person procession through the streets of Gulshan and Banani, replete with 3 kings riding on rickshaws, loyal pages handing out lentils, rice, sweets, juice, biscuits.
As a cultural event it was a disaster, but it did work as a method of distributing food. Firstly, we failed to plan our route very well and so chose to start from one of the only points in Bangladesh where there are no beggars to be found. The first 15 minutes of the procession were panicked as we had no children to share our gifts with, which forced us to over-compensate by going down the road on which there are numerous families trying to live. That is where our second weakness was exposed, as we had no distribution plan. All three Kings were attacked on their rickshaws as people started to grab at the food items, lifting whole bags of rice when they were only supposed to get packets. In some cases it was visible that this occured out of desperation (i.e. very hungry mothers) and in other cases it was plain theft (i.e. very rowdy youths). And this exposed our third weakness, as we hadn't actually discussed what to expect (beyond the original drunken discussion on Christmas Eve).
I thought it was great fun. A complete mess, as noone had a clue as to why foreigners were riding down the road dressed up and giving things out. So the cultural dimension was lost. But also some of the Spanish contingent were sho
A lot of people have since asked why I would do such a thing using words such as proselytising and imperialism. You can get everything in Bangladesh, including $6 loaves of bread like the one I just had for my lunch. But it is hard to rationalise or be accept what you see and experience every single time you leave your house. So on serious note I did help prevent me from going crazy, or to completely cut myself off from the country. On gentler note, it was a lot more fun than NGO work.
